metal roofing

Which Is The Best Choice Metal Roofing or Asphalt Shingle Roofing?


Asphalt shingle and metal shingle roofing are the two available options for your roofing project, and both have their pros and cons. So, it’s crucial to have a detailed understanding regarding which one suits best for your housing as it is a significant long-term investment. Let’s discuss various factors before choosing the most suitable one for your roofing.


When it comes to the appearance of any house or building, asphalt shingles are by far the most popular choice for the builders. There are enough choices for texture and colors available for asphalt shingles that make them visually more appealing. Even though metal comes in a variety of styles and colors as well, but they seem more suitable for the agricultural setting.


Installing the roof can be a dangerous task that requires special skills, expertise, and safety equipment. Generally, asphalt shingle roofing installation is easier as compared to metal roofing. Although to install an asphalt shingle roof, the previous one has to be removed first that is not necessary for metal roofing. A metal roof can be installed easily over the previous roof directly without removing it.

Life expectancy

By adhering to the best roofing practices for their maintenance and choosing the right material according to your environment and climate, you can increase the life expectancy of your roofing material once you get them installed properly. However, asphalt generally has a life expectancy of around 15-20 years or 25-30 years for heavier products. Whereas metal roofing has a length of life around 40-70 years.

Energy efficiency

Asphalt shingles make it difficult for the cooling system of homework efficient as they absorb a lot of heat from the sun.This aspect of asphalt shingles makes them more preferable for the winter season as they keep the temperature of the house warmer. Therefore, asphalt shingles are most recommended for temperate climates. On the other hand, metal roofs are undoubtedly extremely energy efficient and are especially effective in the summer season by reducing energy consumption. However, metal roofs must be installed correctly, or else it makes no difference to their energy efficiency.


The average cost of asphalt shingles ranges between $60-$90 per square, whereas a metal material used for roofing costs around $100-$200 per square. The cost comparison makes asphalt shingles one of the preferable choices, especially for first time home buyers.


Even though metal roofs require low maintenance, their repairs are far more difficult than the asphalt shingles roof. Asphalt shingles roof repair is quite easier and less expensive to replace or repair as compared to a metal roof.

Water, fire and hail resistance

A metal roof is generally more resistant to harsh climatic conditions and fire as it does not rot and can be fortified against rust with a coating. Metal roofs also prevent water damage and seals out water. However, asphalt shingles also have high ratings regarding fire safety, but they can also incur damage from UV rays and hail. Also, some varieties of asphalt are vulnerable to severe climate and weather conditions.

Based on the climatic conditions of North Vancouver, both asphalt and metal roofs can be suitable. However, the final decision should be made based on individual preferences and consultation with a professional roofing contractor. If you are looking for the incredible North Vancouver roofers, you can contact North Vancouver roofing company and contract without a second thought. The team of professionals is undoubtedly the best north Vancouver roofers!

Please share the content, if you found it helpful.
Call Now Button

Let's have a chat

Drop Us A Line For An Obligation Free Quote